Feedback


Here's what people are saying about Dagor Bragollach. . .





Finally Tolkien on a civ2 scenario! Wonderfull! Maybe one of the best scenarios I've ever played, and I've played very much... Thank you for this!
 
-- Balmy




Incredible scenario!!! Very accurate!
 
-- James Lyon




Thanks for a great effort.I have finally got this scenario installed and now I know I should have done it a long time ago.Finding this scenario got me into Civ2.
 
-- Walter Minne




as a scholar of Tolkien, this scenario is wonderful, just great, especially the use of wonders and the girdle of Melian.
 
-- Veon Riluil




One of the best Civ2 scenarios I have ever played. Hope there are more to follow. Keep up the good work...
 
-- Ioannis Coritidis




This is right up there! Hard, but still very fair!I've recommended this to all my friends!
 
-- James Dunne




I played your scenario once on my friends computer. Five minutes after we finished I was back home downloading it myself. Carry on producing games for the good of the world.
 
-- OlorinakaGamdalf




Played your scenario. You have been careful to give it a Silmarillion feel to it even though this restricts the potential of the civ2 engine (which would otherwise distort the background).
 
-- Richard Coates




This has replaced The Lord of the Rings as the most well made and my fav. scenario. Except for the Lotr trilogy, i wasn't much of a Tolkien fan but because of this, i am going to go get the simallarion. Making all the seperate lords guarding there corresponding lands and the hidden city of Gondolin is ingenious. Well, congradulations and hope to hear from you.
 
-- Rebel66




You have achieved a level of scenario building that I have yet to attain. I congradulate you on all of your hard work and dedication, it has truly paid off.
 
-- Adam Wilkie




Your Dagor Bragollach Scenario is one of the best that I've ever played. It beats out 80-90% of the scenarios out on the Net.
 
-- Andrew Janssen




Well, I must say you have outdone yourself this time! I downloaded your version three about a year ago (I guess) and, honestly, never played it more than once due to severe frustration. But this... THIS... this is an absolute masterpiece! I downloaded it about two weeks ago, and really have never stopped playing (well, when I'm free, anyway). Such wonderful additions (Impassible Terrain... who woulda thunk it?!) and Gondolin actually behaves how it should! . . . I had just obtained the Fantastic Worlds Scenario Disk when I downloaded the current version and this ranks better than 90% of the scenarios on it!!
 
-- Scott Hartwell




"Dagor Bragollach", filename Dagor402 - The Battle of Sudden Flame - probably the most extensively rewritten scenario ever uploaded, this game is state-of-the-art in several ways
 
-- Leon Marrick
(cited from his Advanced Scenario Design document)




I downloaded your scenario today, and I must say it's a very impressive piece of work. I haven't had time yet to work through it fully (I'm planning to do that tomorrow) but what I have seen is not only well done in scenario terms, but also thoroughly researched. You've obviously put a lot of effort in on this one.
 
-- Mark Fisher




It is a excellent scenario!
 
-- Mikael




I must say, a glorious scenario. It really are the best I ever played. . .
 
-- Gwindor




After playing your scenario I must say there is little to change. It plays great. Really challenging. I guess I'll let other figure out their own strategies. The Impassable Terrain was genius, I had never thought of that.
 
-- Michael Atwell




. . .It is one of the best I've played. . .
 
-- Lord Gaeras Draugurth of Kheleklad




What can i tell about scenario? It's cool... Sorry my errors, i am from Russia and i know englsih bad.. :-)
 
-- Alekcey Petrov




Hi, I just wanted to say I love your scenarios :)
 
-- Monika Bender




Thank you Hurin for one of the best scenaro on the net. It�s as good as my favourite The Lord of the Ring of Harland.
 
-- Ola Lindstrom




. . . I downloaded your scenario. And let me tell you, I can't stop playing it. I have even started re-reading the Silmarillion. It is one of the top three scenarios I have ever downloaded, and I have downloaded a lot of them. Well, to sum it all up, your scenario kicks some major @ss.
 
-- R. Treat




Hi I really love your game I am a huge fan of tolkien and especially the silmarillion I think you've done a great job. . .
 
-- Bev Nott




Your Dagor scenario is awesome! I haven't beaten it yet, but it's really cool.
 
-- Alpha




Your Dagor Bragollach scenario for Civ II is really well made, I congratulate you.
 
-- James Persaud




I am really impressed with the scenario you have produced!
 
-- Richard Lally




Found your site and picked up your scenario. Very impressive. Having worked on scenarios I can appreciate the amount of time you've invested. Yours is a unique use of the Civ II game engine and it works quite well. Your method of creating "impassable" terrain is interesting and I've promptly "stolen" it for use in a scenario that I'm working on, loosely based on the Riverworld series of stories.
 
-- Dick Knisley




Posting Your Comments

Unfortunately, the form used to post comments had to be disabled when Dor-lomin was transferred to a newer server. However you may post comments and feedback on the Dor-lomin Forums. Any especially insightful (or glowing!) reviews will be manually moved to this feedback page. Thanks!

If you have a question rather than a comment, please email me privately at hurin@dor-lomin.com.